Smoke Gets in Your Eyes — and Stays in Your Heart: Celebrating The Platters

The Platters, formed in Los Angeles in 1953, emerged as one of the most influential vocal groups of the early rock and roll era. Their harmonious blend of rhythm and blues with pop sensibilities captivated audiences worldwide, leaving an indelible mark on music history.

Origins and Formation

The group was founded by bass singer Herb Reed, who, after moving from Kansas City to Los Angeles, began performing with friends on street corners. The original lineup included Alex Hodge, Cornell Gunter, Joe Jefferson, Gaynel Hodge, and later, Reed himself. The name The Platters was inspired by the term for vinyl records, reflecting their musical aspirations.

Initially managed by Ralph Bass of Federal Records, the group underwent several lineup changes over the years. Tony Williams replaced Gunter as lead vocalist, and Zola Taylor joined as the first female member, adding a unique dynamic to the ensemble. Despite early recordings, commercial success eluded them until they teamed up with manager and songwriter Buck Ram.

Rise to Stardom

Under Ram’s guidance, The Platters signed with Mercury Records and re-recorded “Only You (And You Alone),” which became their breakthrough hit in 1955. This was followed by “The Great Pretender,” solidifying their status in the music industry. Their polished sound and emotive performances resonated with a broad audience. 

Since then, some of The Platters’ greatest hits have included “My Prayer,” “Twilight Time,” and “Smoke Gets in Your Eyes.”  Their success extended beyond records; they appeared in the 1956 film Rock Around the Clock, bringing their music to the silver screen and further expanding their fan base.

Challenges and Changes

In 1959, the group faced a significant setback when members were arrested in Ohio under racially charged circumstances. Although acquitted, the incident tarnished their reputation, leading to decreased airplay in the US. Consequently, they focused on international markets, becoming one of the first African American groups to achieve global superstardom.​

The 1960s brought further changes. Tony Williams departed to pursue a solo career, and Sonny Turner stepped in as lead vocalist. The group continued to produce hits such as “I Love You 1000 Times” and “With This Ring,” adapting to the evolving music landscape.​

Legacy and Influence

Despite numerous lineup changes and legal battles over the group’s name, The Platters’ legacy endured. Their contributions to music were recognized with inductions into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1990 and the Vocal Group Hall of Fame in 1998. Herb Reed, the only member to perform with the group throughout its entire history, fought to protect the group’s name and legacy until his death in 2012.​ The band has been managed by Frederick J. Balboni Jr. since then.

Today, The Platters continue to perform, introducing their timeless sound to new generations and solidifying their place in the annals of music history.

See The Platters at Main Street Crossing

See The Platters perform in an intimate setting at Main Street Crossing (MSC) on June 21, 2025, at 4 and 8 p.m. Click here to purchase tickets. 

MSC in Tomball, Texas, is one of the best small music venues in the Houston metro area. This unique nonprofit in a historic venue hosts country, Americana, folk, blues, and other types of music artists in an intimate setting: The furthest seat is only 45 feet from the stage. MSC also offers food, beverages, table service, and community seating, making it easier to interact with fellow concertgoers and even performing artists. Parking is convenient and stress-free.

MSC also functions as a multiuse venue for church services, concerts, and more in Tomball. Check out our event calendar, and enjoy entertainment in support of good causes!